Basic Cookies

 starting at $36/dozen

  • 1-2 Design per Dozen

  • Standard Shapes

  • 1-2 Icing Colors

  • Minimal Layered Details


Detailed Cookies

starting at $45/dozen

  • 4 Designs per Dozen

  • Standard or Custom Shapes

  • 4 - 5 Icing Colors

  • Moderare Layered Details

Elaborate Cookies

Starting at $50/dozen

  • 4-5 Designs per Dozen

  • Custom Hand Cut Designs

  • 4-5 Icing Colors

  • Several Layered Details,

  • metallic hand painted details

Mini Cookies

Starting at $18/dozen


Logo Cookies

  • Starting at $4.00/cookie

  • Large Quantities(200+) $2/cookie

                                                                   Custom Cookie Order


In order to help stream line this process for me, please fill out the form to inquire about an order.

There is a minimum order of 2 dozen regular or 3 dozen minis.

I require 50% of the price as retainer fee on all custom orders within 48 hours of receiving invoice. Retainer fee is required in order to secure your date. The fee will then be put toward the total bill. Please pay with cash, check to Penny Bakes LLC, PayPal ( or credit cards. Retainer can only be refunded if order is canceled at least 7 days ahead of the scheduled pick up day. I reserve the right to cancel your order in the case of illness or family emergency, in which case you will receive a full refund.


Cookies and Cakes must be picked up from my home unless delivery has been arranged and agreed upon. The delivery fee is $1.00/mile within 10 mile radius of 32804.  Remainder of payment is due at pick-up or delivery.

I typically require a minimum of 2 weeks notice for custom orders.

If you have pictures of what you have in mind please email to or text to 407-504-1917

I currently do not carry vegan or gluten free options. I also do not ship cookies. 

Although I can make nut-free cookies, I do not guarantee that I work in a completely nut-free kitchen. 

*Please double check your junk mail when waiting for a reply from me. It seems as though my e-mails get sent there often.*

Get a Quote